Listen to this article
Take the story with you. Choose a voice and a pace that suits you.
Or listen in another language / choose a voice
Getting your device voices ready…
The voice follows the displayed language and your browser’s regional preference when available. You can choose another narration voice.
Mohist consequentialism vs utilitarianism sounds like a tidy comparison, the kind textbooks love. A new book says the tidiness is the problem. Consequentialism in the Mohist Tradition by Bradford Kim, a lecturer in philosophy at the University of Southampton, was published online by Oxford University Press on 19 October, with the print edition following on 17 November 2026 (source).
Kim’s target is a habit of reading. Mohism, a major movement in ancient Chinese philosophy and an early rival to Confucian thought, holds that the right course of action is the one that benefits the world (source). That sounds close to Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. Kim argues it is not close enough — and that the difference matters for how we treat people we disagree with, or people whose conduct we condemn.
Information verified through 18 November 2026.
What is Mohist inclusive care, in the Mohists’ own terms?
Start with the school itself. Mohism takes its name from Mozi, also rendered Master Mo, who presented a rival tradition to the Confucians during the Warring States period, when Confucian thought was still developing (source). Confucian thought went on to dominate East Asia, while Mohist thought faded into obscurity for over two thousand years, yet the publisher’s synopsis notes a broad consensus that Confucian philosophy gained much of its sophistication from having to answer Mohist criticism (source).
The core, as Kim presents it, has two parts: what is right is what benefits the world, and when we benefit the world we should inclusively care (source). Inclusive care is the outlook. Benefit is the test.
That pairing is why the Mohists are often called the first consequentialist theorists in history — their key principle is that what makes an action right is that it benefits the world, as Kim’s University of Southampton research profile puts it (source). It is also where the familiar comparison begins, and where Kim says it goes wrong.
Early and later Mohist texts benefit differently
Bentham and Mill, in the standard account Kim is pushing against, hold that what is right is what promotes happiness, and that in the calculation everyone counts equally (source). Virtually all commentators, Kim’s profile notes, have attributed that same equal moral consideration to the Mohists (source).
His reading splits the tradition in two. The early texts conceive of benefit in terms of aggregates — states, for example — rather than the individuals who compose them, indicating a prioritisation of aggregates over individuals (source). The later texts conceive of benefit in terms of aggregated individuals instead (source).
Even the later model, which looks nearer to Bentham and Mill, diverges at the crucial point. Mohism, Kim argues, does not extend equal moral consideration to everyone: early Mohism does not extend it to poor moral performers, whereas later Mohism selectively extends it on the basis of what will benefit the world in context (source).
This builds on Kim’s earlier journal work. In a 2024 article he argued the Mohists may have been the first consequentialists on earth, that early Mohists were objective-list consequentialists promoting basic goods, and that direct texts preclude reading the later Mohists as simple preference-satisfaction consequentialists (source). The book, running to 192 pages, gathers that line of argument into a single account (source).
Bradford Kim Consequentialism in the Mohist Tradition and the people ‘beyond the pale’
Why should anyone outside ancient philosophy care who counts, and how much, in a Warring States text?
Kim’s own framing gives the answer. His university profile describes the book as a timely investigation into how one should treat those with whom one has a suboptimal relationship, whether because of moral disagreement or because the other person has committed acts considered ‘beyond the pale’ (source). Southampton’s announcement similarly stresses that Kim explores how the tradition’s understanding of benefit and moral consideration developed, including the relationship between individuals and wider society (source).
Analysis: the Mohist position, on Kim’s reading, is uncomfortable in a useful way. Modern moral talk often assumes a clean choice — count everyone equally, always, or abandon impartiality altogether. The later Mohists, as he presents them, did neither. They kept benefit to the world as the standard and let moral consideration expand or contract with context. You can disagree with that flexibility. It can look like a licence to write people off. But it also names something real in public life: societies do, in practice, argue about whether serious wrongdoing changes what a person is owed, and they rarely settle it by counting everyone identically in every case.
Read that way, the book is not an attempt to recruit Mozi as a utilitarian before utilitarianism. It is a warning against flattening a foreign tradition into a familiar one — and a reminder that the question of who counts has been argued, carefully and differently, for a very long time.
Photo: via Wikimedia Commons (CC0)
Sources
- https://magazines.soton.ac.uk/fah/2026/11/03/southampton-academics-new-book-rethinks-consequentialism-through-ancient-chinese-philosophy/
- https://www.southampton.ac.uk/people/65djlr/doctor-bradford-kim
- https://www.wordery.com/book/consequentialism-in-the-mohist-tradition/bradford-jean-hyuk-kim/9780197909560
- https://www.booktopia.com.au/consequentialism-in-the-mohist-tradition-bradford-jean-hyuk-kim/ebook/9780197909539.html
- https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/489179/

Leave a comment
Comment as a guest and verify your email, or sign in or create a reader account. Guest comments reach our review queue after email verification; account holders can submit directly for review.