Listen to this article
Take the story with you. Choose a voice and a pace that suits you.
Or listen in another language / choose a voice
Getting your device voices ready…
The voice follows the displayed language and your browser’s regional preference when available. You can choose another narration voice.
Lock the phone away and the grades will follow. That was the hope, anyway. A national study of school phone bans and test scores, reported on 17 November 2026, tested the idea across more than 4,600 schools and found something less tidy: phones went quiet, teachers breathed easier, and test scores — for the most part — stayed where they were.
Information verified through 19 November 2026.
The study, The Effects of School Phone Bans: National Evidence from Lockable Pouches, was published as a working paper by the National Bureau of Economic Research, according to The EDU Ledger. Its authors came from Stanford University, Duke University, the University of Pennsylvania and the University of Michigan. They did not look at every kind of rule. They looked at one clear intervention: schools where pupils carry their phones in magnetically sealed Yondr pouches, opened only at the end of the day.
That narrow focus was deliberate. Stanford’s report on the research explains that comparing schools with an unambiguous intervention to schools without one gave the team a cleaner read than mixing together locker rules, classroom-only rules and outright bans. As of early 2026, a reported three million students across US schools were using Yondr pouches, Stanford notes.
School phone bans and test scores: first, the phones really did go away
On its own terms, the policy worked. Teachers at adopting schools reported that the share of students using phones in class for personal reasons fell from 61% to 13%, according to The EDU Ledger’s summary of the findings. Teacher satisfaction with their school’s phone policy rose from about 26% to 75%. Location data told a similar story, with device activity on campus falling by roughly 30% by the third year after a school adopted pouches.
So nobody needs to wonder whether a locked pouch stops scrolling in third period. It does. The harder question — do school phone bans improve learning once the screens go dark? — is where the numbers thin out.
Do school phone bans improve learning? The test-score answer
Average standardised test score gains were essentially zero across the first three years after adoption, the researchers found (The EDU Ledger). High schools did a little better. Their maths achievement rose by about 0.9 percentile points. Middle schools moved the other way, with small declines. Stanford’s own account puts it plainly: banning phones during the school day did not improve standardised test scores over a three-year period.
Attendance refused to budge too. Rates of absence and chronic absenteeism showed virtually no measurable improvement, according to the study summary. Nor did the team find clear evidence that pupils paid more attention in class on their own reporting, or that online bullying fell.
Anyone selling pouches as a shortcut to higher scores now has a problem. The largest dataset assembled on these policies — the team calls it the first full national dataset on school phone policies, per Stanford — does not back the sales pitch.
A rough first year, then a steadier picture
The early months were not smooth. Disciplinary incidents rose in the first year of implementation, corresponding to an estimated 15% rise in suspension rates, before those effects faded in later years (The EDU Ledger). Reported well-being followed a similar arc. The study found suggestive evidence that students’ subjective well-being dipped at first, then recovered and turned positive two years later — though the researchers cautioned that the well-being findings rest on thinner survey data and are less conclusive.
The school cellphone bans attendance well-being ledger, in other words, has entries on both sides. That pattern matters for how schools judge a new rule. Assessed in its first term, the policy looks worse than the same policy in its third year. A dip that recovers is a different thing from lasting harm, and the researchers were careful not to overclaim either way.
Teachers helped design the questions
One reason this study reads differently from earlier skirmishes in the phone wars is who shaped it. Stanford reports that educators helped decide which outcomes to track from the start — phone use, test scores, attendance, well-being and online bullying among them. Angela Duckworth, of the University of Pennsylvania, called that close work with teachers and administrators one of the project’s “great triumphs,” noting that teachers wanted pupils to pay attention and learn, but also to develop social skills and connection.
The scale of that input is hard to miss. A survey run alongside the study drew nearly 108,000 educator responses from all 50 states, according to Stanford and The EDU Ledger. Students themselves were not surveyed directly — a gap Duckworth and Gentzkow say they want to close.
Context explains the urgency. Nearly half of US teenagers told Pew in 2024 that they are online “almost constantly,” a figure Stanford cites. Roughly two-thirds of US states had legislated to limit student phone access by 2026, and nearly 5,000 schools had adopted pouches, per the researchers (The EDU Ledger). Policy ran ahead of evidence. This study is the evidence catching up.
Analysis: The result should not be read as “bans do nothing.” It shows a specific, strict intervention doing exactly one job well — cutting phone use — while leaving the deeper drivers of achievement untouched. Gentzkow makes a version of that point himself in Stanford’s report: take away a distraction and you have not fixed curriculum, teaching quality or school culture. Duckworth puts the principals’ real question well — not whether to restrict phones, but how, when pupils may use them, and how rules get enforced fairly after that first, bumpier year.
Schools can still choose a ban. Calmer corridors and happier teachers are real gains, and the Yondr pouches study results give leaders an honest basis for deciding. What the data will not support is promising parents a jump in grades. That promise was never in the pouch.
Photo: Airman Daekwon Stith, via Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)
Sources
- Stanford News — Do school phone bans make a difference? https://news.stanford.edu/stories/2026/11/school-phone-bans-research
- The EDU Ledger — School Phone Bans Slash Cellphone Use but Show Little Academic Benefit, Study Finds https://www.theeduledger.com/institutions/article/16541775/school-phone-bans-slash-cellphone-use-but-show-little-academic-benefit-study-finds
- Education Post — School phone bans reduce mobile use but show little impact on test scores, Stanford study finds https://educationpost.in/news/education/school-phone-bans-reduce-mobile-use-but-show-little-impact-on-test-scores-stanford-study-finds

Leave a comment
Comment as a guest and verify your email, or sign in or create a reader account. Guest comments reach our review queue after email verification; account holders can submit directly for review.