Is No Such Thing as Monday worth reading? This assessment is based on the published criticism around Siân Hughes’s novel, which was published in the United States by Henry Holt on 10 November 2026, at 224 pages, rather than on a reading of our own. On that evidence the answer is a strong yes, with a caveat about pace and darkness that the reviewers themselves raise. The book arrived with momentum: Hughes’s previous novel, Pearl (2023), was longlisted for the Booker Prize, and the new one promptly topped the week’s review tallies.

Is No Such Thing as Monday worth reading? The tally: Book Marks best reviewed books of the week

Start with the scoreboard. In Book Marks’ round-up of the best reviewed books of the week, published by Literary Hub on 13 November, No Such Thing As Monday ranked first in fiction with five rave reviews, two positive and one mixed. That is not a shutout, and the one mixed notice matters — it is addressed below — but no other fiction title that week matched the spread.

The rave quoted by Literary Hub is the New York Times review by Leah Greenblatt, who calls the novel “fractious and darkly funny” and its narrator “spiky, sharp-witted, blazingly self-aware.” Greenblatt’s verdict, as excerpted there, is that Hughes “has a canny, lyrical ear for her misfits and underdogs, and a touch tender enough to nudge their fate toward better things” — praise aimed squarely at voice and character rather than plot machinery.

What the No Such Thing as Monday reviews say the book is

The No Such Thing as Monday reviews agree on the shape of the story. Stephanie — Steffie — Cartwright is a middle-aged woman working at a dry cleaner’s in working-class England who finds her father, Stan, dead in his chair, and whose account moves between the present and a childhood in 1970s Birmingham. The Chicago Review of Books describes a novel that spans Steffie’s lifetime, childhood to middle age, following abandonment, familial guilt, favoritism, and poverty, with Stan favouring Steffie over her older sister, Caroline, who left home at 16 and has been absent for some 30 years.

The engine of the book, per the Chicago review, is the search for that sister and the guilt attached to her absence. Steffie, it says, is “compelling, not always likeable, but certainly never unlikeable”, and the chapters work like pages in a photo album, each widening the picture. Reading Matters fills in the childhood the album holds: a father who made money fighting in pubs while his frightened wife took in ironing for 12-hour stints, Caroline denied food and beaten, Steffie inexplicably spared — and, later, abandonment, a stint ferrying drugs, jail, and the dry-cleaning job she is still doing in middle age.

The title, reviewers explain, names the family’s method of survival: pretending a thing does not exist — Monday skipped between Sunday and Tuesday — rather than speaking of it, above all of Caroline.

The reservation, and who this Sian Hughes Pearl follow-up novel is for

The mixed notice in the tally is worth taking seriously, because it identifies the book’s real risk. The Times, in its review, found that as the narrative moves into Steffie’s violent childhood, the dark comedy recedes, and judged the novel “a decent follow-up to Pearl” that positions itself, by design, as the lesser work — while still crediting Hughes’s handling of memory and calling Steffie “vicious and defensive and prickly,” determined to avoid self-pity. Reader reviews collected on The StoryGraph strike a similar caution from the other side: the pace is slow, the tone melancholy, the subject matter intense.

Set against that, the warmth in the favourable reviews is unusually specific. Reading Matters praises a portrait of life on the margins that never mocks its subject or turns hardship into “poverty porn,” calling the novel “full of heart and wonderful, biting humour”. The Chicago Review of Books closes by calling it “a powerful story that unveils itself with every page”.

Analysis: as a recommendation, this is a voice purchase. Every strand of the criticism — rave, positive and mixed alike — agrees that Steffie’s narration is the book: funny in a way that makes the bleak material bearable, and unsparing in a way that keeps the humour honest. Readers who want plot momentum or lightness should heed The Times and the slow-pace warnings. Readers who liked Pearl, or who read for a narrator they will argue with and miss afterwards, have the strongest-reviewed British novel of its week waiting for them.

Photo: Andy Li, via Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

Sources

  1. Chicago Review of Books — “No Such Thing As Monday” Is a Photo Album of One Woman’s Trauma and Triumphs: https://chireviewofbooks.com/2026/11/11/no-such-thing-as-monday-is-a-photo-album-of-one-womans-trauma-and-triumphs/
  2. Literary Hub / Book Marks — What Should You Read Next? Here Are the Best Reviewed Books of the Week: https://lithub.com/what-should-you-read-next-here-are-the-best-reviewed-books-of-the-week-11-13-2026/
  3. Reading Matters — ‘No Such Thing as Monday’ by Sian Hughes: https://readingmattersblog.com/2026/08/22/no-such-thing-as-monday-by-sian-hughes/
  4. The Times — A gritty modern black comedy inspired by a medieval poem (review of No Such Thing as Monday): https://www.thetimes.com/culture/books/article/no-such-thing-as-monday-sian-hughes-review-h27x3mbtj

THE READER CONVERSATION

What’s your perspective?

Bring a question, a different reading or something the story made you notice. All comments are reviewed before they appear. Disagreement is welcome; harassment, advertising and personal attacks are not.

No approved comments yet. Start the conversation.

Leave a comment

Comment as a guest and verify your email, or sign in or create a reader account. Guest comments reach our review queue after email verification; account holders can submit directly for review.

10–2,000 characters. Up to one web link. Keep it relevant and respectful; do not share private personal information.

How we handle reader information. This does not subscribe you to the newsletter.

Preparing the secure form…