Is Flesh by David Szalay worth reading? Start with the odd fact: the novel that won the 2025 Booker Prize is built around a man who barely speaks. István answers the world with “Yeah” and “Okay”. Whole conversations pass in shrugs. Yet the judges talked about the six shortlisted books for more than five hours and kept circling back to this one. Chair Roddy Doyle put it plainly: “We had never read anything quite like it. It is, in many ways, a dark book but it is a joy to read.” Information verified through 17 November 2026.

The short answer is yes — with one condition. You have to be willing to do some of the work yourself. Szalay leaves the gaps open on purpose, and the gaps are where this book lives.

Is Flesh by David Szalay worth reading if you need a hero who talks?

Probably not, and that is the gamble. Doyle praised the white space above everything else: “I don’t think I’ve read a novel that uses the white space on the page so well. It’s as if the author, David Szalay, is inviting the reader to fill the space, to observe — almost to create — the character with him.” Judge Sarah Jessica Parker called the book “hypnotically tense and compelling”, per the novel’s published record).

Not every critic surrendered. In The New York Times, Dwight Garner called it a “cool, remote novel” about male alienation and admitted: “I admired this book from front to back without ever quite liking it.” The Wall Street Journal found the scarcity of inner life hypnotic; The Daily Telegraph‘s Cal Revely-Calder went the other way, calling it “half the novel it could have been”. That split is useful. This Flesh by David Szalay review lands on the admiring side — but if Garner’s sentence sounds like a warning rather than an invitation, believe him. He is describing the same book.

One life, told in leaps: estate, army, London

Flesh is Szalay’s sixth novel, published by Jonathan Cape in Britain in March 2025 and by Scribner in the United States that April. It follows István from a Hungarian housing estate to the top of London money, and then down the other side. A detailed review in Shiny New Books walks the route: a teenage István is drawn into a relationship with a married neighbour in her forties, a fight follows, her husband dies, and the boy is blamed and sent to a young offender facility. Army service takes him to Iraq, where a comrade is killed. London gives him work as a bouncer, then a job driving for a rich couple. He becomes the wife Helen’s lover, marries her after her husband dies, and steps into property and luxury he never learned how to inhabit.

One warning belongs here, because reviews owe readers honesty about content: the opening movement involves a boy of fifteen and an adult woman. Szalay writes it flatly, without titillation, and the damage echoes through everything after. Still, some readers will want to know before page one.

What Szalay skips is as striking as what he shows. Years vanish between chapters; turning points happen offstage, and the story resumes with István already living inside the result.

István in Flesh by David Szalay: a man his body decides for

Why does a character this passive hold a whole novel? Because the passivity is the subject. Published summaries describe a man who acts on instinct first and reflects later, if at all — someone whose body seems to know things his mind does not. Szalay said he wanted the novel to express the feeling that “our existence is a physical experience before it is anything else”. Hence the title. Sex, violence, work, ageing: István meets all of it physically and almost none of it verbally.

The critics who loved the book praise exactly that restraint. Keiran Goddard in The Guardian wrote that the novel is about “what is fundamentally unsayable, the ineffable things that sit at the centre of every life”. Luke Brown in the Financial Times called it “a moving work of art with a plot that compels and surprises and devastates”. The Associated Press credited the “straightforward, spare prose” with propelling a tragic story.

Szalay had personal ground to stand on. The Flesh David Szalay Booker Prize 2025 win made him the first Hungarian-British writer to take the prize; he received £50,000, presented by the previous winner Samantha Harvey, from a field of 153 submitted books, and he had been shortlisted before, in 2016, for All That Man Is. He told BBC Radio, as reported by AAP: “I really wanted to write a book that stretched between Hungary and London and involved a character who was not quite at home in either place.”

Who should pick it up, and who should pass

Pick it up if you read for sentences and structure rather than confession, or if Hemingway’s restraint and Hardy’s fatalism — the comparisons the Shiny New Books review reaches for — sound like company you keep. Book clubs should do well with it too: so much is left open to argue about, from István’s culpability to whether the ending is punishment or just entropy.

Pass if you need interior monologue, warmth on the page, or a protagonist who grows in ways he can articulate. István does change — reviewers note a slow gain in empathy — but he will never explain himself to you.

A last practical note: film rights were optioned in November 2025 by House Productions, BBC Film and Access Entertainment, per the novel’s record. Reading it now means meeting István before a screen version decides what his face looks like — and the whole novel asks you to create him yourself.

Photo: Charpentier, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

Sources

  1. https://thebookerprizes.com/the-booker-library/features/everything-you-need-to-know-about-flesh-booker-prize-2025-winner
  2. https://shinynewbooks.co.uk/flesh-by-david-szalay
  3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flesh_(Szalay_novel)
  4. https://aapnews.aap.com.au/news/david-szalay-s-novel-flesh-wins-booker-prize

THE READER CONVERSATION

What’s your perspective?

Bring a question, a different reading or something the story made you notice. All comments are reviewed before they appear. Disagreement is welcome; harassment, advertising and personal attacks are not.

No approved comments yet. Start the conversation.

Leave a comment

Comment as a guest and verify your email, or sign in or create a reader account. Guest comments reach our review queue after email verification; account holders can submit directly for review.

10–2,000 characters. Up to one web link. Keep it relevant and respectful; do not share private personal information.

How we handle reader information. This does not subscribe you to the newsletter.

Preparing the secure form…