SKIMS promised “twelve days of fun surprises.” For $148, buyers got a tartan teddy bear keychain, hair ties, scrunchies, bobby pins — twice — and a foam SKIMS-logo squishy. Not one piece of clothing. Nothing about that box counted as a problem until one customer filmed herself opening it and tens of millions of people watched — which is why this is an opinion piece.

Twelve doors, more than $12 a door

The SKIMS Accessories Advent Calendar launched on October 29 in the brand’s Holiday Shop, priced at $148. One count of what sat behind its twelve doors: six scrunchies, six bobby pins, four keychains (a tartan bear, a comb, a logo, a faux-fur compact mirror), three hair ties, two logo hair clips, two headbands made from bra elastic, and a foam squishy. That is the whole product.

SKIMS once sold an advent calendar of 25 pairs of underwear for $450 — steep, but at least it was the product the brand is famous for. This time, the family name did all the work. One point of fairness: the contents were listed on the product page, tucked under the fit and fabric details — disclosed quietly, in the small print, beneath marketing promising “a mix of playful items and everyday favorites.”

One video, and the refund desk opened

On November 6, TikTok creator @wetsloppyswollen opened all twelve doors on camera. “Kimberly, you’re genuinely about to piss me off,” she said partway through. “This is way too expensive.” Holding up a headband, she asked: “What is this? A bra strap made into a hair tie?” The video passed 65 million views in 72 hours and has since climbed past 79 million. She closed it by telling her followers: “I just saved the Christmas spirit and the Christmas season.” She was not alone: another buyer’s unboxing passed 22 million views and rated it zero out of ten; an Instagram reviewer scored it five out of ten and called the contents leftover brand samples.

The verdict arrived in the comments, everywhere at once. “Temu junk.” A “box full of pranks.” Contents like “basically everything that falls between my car seats,” like the bottom of an old school backpack. On Facebook, TMZ’s refund post drew over 13,000 reactions, the most common being laughter — 5,000-plus “Haha” against single-digit anger. On Instagram, a handmade cardboard “SKAMS” parody calendar outperformed every straight unboxing, and fashion watchdog Diet Prada devoted nine slides to it. “The real gift,” one commenter wrote there, “was discovering that disappointment now comes in 12 individually wrapped pieces.” On Trustpilot — where buyer reviews survive, because the pulled listing took SKIMS’ own reviews with it — one buyer called the calendar “absolutely disgusting” and “barely worth $10 all together”; another called it “a grift not a gift.” On Reddit, the leading verdict on r/entertainment called the calendar “straight up open contempt,” and one social-listening count put negative posts ahead of positive ones by roughly eight to one. Across platforms, buyers put the real value of the contents somewhere between $5 and $20.

SKIMS moved only when the numbers did. On November 8 the brand told TODAY it had listened carefully and contacted buyers. On November 9, in a statement carried by Page Six and an email to customers, SKIMS admitted its team had “fell short”: return the calendar for a full refund, return shipping waived, or keep it and take $150 in store credit. The BBC reported the refunds. The calendar was pulled from sale, and its product page now redirects to the general accessories collection. Note the order of events. The calendar did not become refund-worthy when it shipped. It became refund-worthy at 65 million views.

Then a cofounder called them “haters”

On November 10, TMZ stopped Emma Grede — SKIMS’ founding partner and chief product officer — and asked what she would say to the haters, meaning the people who had been judging the calendar. “You know, I don’t worry about the haters,” Grede answered. “It’s a new day!” Her defenders note, correctly, that the word came from the reporter’s question. But the question named the very buyers the brand had apologised to days earlier, and the answer she chose waved them off anyway. Kim Kardashian herself has so far stayed publicly silent over it all — and on its own feeds, so has SKIMS: the brand posted 33 times in the two weeks after the video, all product content, and never mentioned the calendar, the backlash or the refunds. The entire response ran through buyer emails and spokespeople.

“Get your ass up and work”

In March 2022, promoting The Kardashians, Kim Kardashian gave Variety her best advice for women in business: “Get your fucking ass up and work. It seems like nobody wants to work these days.” She later apologised on Good Morning America, saying the line had been taken out of context — a claim Variety’s own reporter publicly disputed after reviewing the raw footage.

Set that lecture beside this calendar. Somebody at SKIMS had to choose these items, price them at $148, write “twelve days of fun surprises” over them and ship them to the most loyal customers a brand can have — people who buy a mystery box on faith because the name on it is Kardashian. That choosing, pricing and checking was the work. It was not done. The woman who told millions of working women that nobody wants to work anymore fronts a company that could not be bothered to do the basic work of making a $148 box worth $148.

A pattern, not an accident

This family has monetised the name first and done the homework second before. In 2019 Kardashian announced her shapewear line under the name “Kimono” and moved to trademark the word itself. It took a petition of more than 130,000 signatures and a letter from the mayor of Kyoto before the name was dropped and SKIMS was born. Nor was this calendar a solo venture — its holiday collection was fronted by Kim and her sisters as one family brand. The name on the box is the family’s. The family’s business is the name.

Our verdict (opinion)

Here is the part that should make people angry. $148 is not play money to the people who bought this calendar. It is a week of groceries, a utility bill, a shift’s pay — handed over by working people to some of the richest entertainers on earth, people who present themselves as business leaders and lecture the public about work ethic. What those working people received was the contents of a junk drawer with a logo printed on it, an apology that arrived only when a video grew too large to ignore, and a cofounder shrugging them off as haters. Bored Panda summed up that shrug in a headline: “This is how the rich see us.” It is, in a word, disgusting. The refunds do not change what the calendar revealed. They only prove the family responds to pressure — never to conscience.

Photo: Nicole Alexander / Vimeo, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0)

Sources

  • Page Six — SKIMS’ November 9 statement and refund offer
  • BBC News — refunds, pricing and the buyer email
  • TODAY — SKIMS’ November 8 statement
  • TMZ — Emma Grede’s “haters” remark, November 10
  • Variety — the March 2022 “get your ass up and work” interview
  • Trustpilot — buyer reviews of the advent calendar

THE READER CONVERSATION

What’s your perspective?

Bring a question, a different reading or something the story made you notice. All comments are reviewed before they appear. Disagreement is welcome; harassment, advertising and personal attacks are not.

No approved comments yet. Start the conversation.

Leave a comment

Comment as a guest and verify your email, or sign in or create a reader account. Guest comments reach our review queue after email verification; account holders can submit directly for review.

10–2,000 characters. Up to one web link. Keep it relevant and respectful; do not share private personal information.

How we handle reader information. This does not subscribe you to the newsletter.

Preparing the secure form…