Two-speed holiday spending 2026 is not a metaphor in search of data. It is the headline finding of Alvarez & Marsal’s Fall 2026 Consumer Sentiment Survey, released on 12 November from a nationally representative survey of over 2,000 US adults fielded in late August and early September. Overall spending intent sits at +4% net, its highest level since Fall 2023. That average is the least interesting number in the report. Underneath it, two different Christmases are being planned. Information verified through 17 November 2026.

Two-speed holiday spending 2026 starts with two different pay packets

Start with earnings, because the spending follows from them. Among households earning over $100,000, the net expectation to earn more jumped 10 points to 63%, and intent to spend more rose 7 points to 25%. Households below that line moved the other way: earning expectations slipped 2 points to 40%, yet spending expectations still rose 3 points — made possible by a 6 point drop in savings intent to 22%.

Read that again. One group spends because it expects to earn. The other spends by saving less. Chad Lusk, a managing director in A&M’s Consumer and Retail Group, put it bluntly: lower-income households are “giving up savings to keep up with essentials like groceries and utilities, not because they expect to earn more. That is a far less stable foundation heading into the holidays.” The survey puts the savings gap between the two groups at 18 points, the widest since Fall 2023.

Higher income households holiday spending 2026 survey: where the money goes

The holiday table is where the split turns into shopping lists. Total holiday spending intent is −14% net, down from roughly −3% last fall. Higher-income households plan +18% net, led by holiday meals and treats at +21% and travel at +17%; decorations, at −4%, are the only line they trim. Lower-income households cut every holiday category at −26% net — shallowest on gifts for others (−16%), deepest on decorations (−43%), with travel at −36% and gifts for themselves at −34%.

Notice the order of the cuts. Presents for other people are protected longest; presents for yourself go first. That is not a statistic about retail. It is a statistic about what people refuse to give up.

Promotions still run the calendar for everyone. About half of consumers wait for events like Black Friday and Cyber Monday, yet 37% would buy a desired gift immediately if it were running low in stock. RetailWire’s discussion of the survey notes the figures can still square with industry forecasts of 4–5% holiday sales growth: prices and affluent shoppers can lift the dollar total while most households do less.

Store brands, lower priced grocers, and a GLP-1 grocery basket

Away from the holidays, the same households shop with the same split brain. The shift to lower-priced grocers is sticking: 26% of consumers planning to spend less on groceries will keep their brands but switch to a less expensive store, up from 16% in Fall 2025, and roughly seven in ten shoppers now rate those grocers at parity with traditional supermarkets. Store brands have gone fully mainstream: 84% say they are more affordable than national brands, 69% rate their quality as good as or better, and 71% say they meet their dietary or lifestyle needs.

Then there is the basket itself. The survey reports 22% of respondents currently taking a GLP-1 medication, up from 18% in the spring — a figure A&M itself flags as above national estimates, so read it as direction, not census. Because those shoppers eat less, they rebuild around protein and nutrition, and everyone else is drifting the same way: 46% now choose snacks for beneficial ingredients such as protein and fiber, up from 37%, and protein, at 43%, is the benefit shoppers will pay most to get.

Analysis: the survey’s own firm says value now has to be demonstrable — on the shelf and on the screen. The deeper story is simpler. Christmas 2026 will probably post respectable sales numbers, and those numbers will describe the smaller, richer half of the country doing the spending. For the other half, the season is being funded out of the savings jar. Both halves will call it a normal December. Only one of them can afford to.

Sources

  1. https://financewire.com/2026/11/12/alvarez-marsal-releases-fall-2026-consumer-sentiment-survey-highlighting-uneven-spending-recovery/
  2. https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2026/11/12/3401698/0/en/alvarez-marsal-releases-fall-2026-consumer-sentiment-survey-highlighting-uneven-spending-recovery.html
  3. https://alvarezandmarsal-crg.com/insight/consumer-sentiment-survey-fall-2026/
  4. https://retailwire.com/discussion/two-speed-christmas-shoppers-retailers-this-year/

THE READER CONVERSATION

What’s your perspective?

Bring a question, a different reading or something the story made you notice. All comments are reviewed before they appear. Disagreement is welcome; harassment, advertising and personal attacks are not.

No approved comments yet. Start the conversation.

Leave a comment

Comment as a guest and verify your email, or sign in or create a reader account. Guest comments reach our review queue after email verification; account holders can submit directly for review.

10–2,000 characters. Up to one web link. Keep it relevant and respectful; do not share private personal information.

How we handle reader information. This does not subscribe you to the newsletter.

Preparing the secure form…